I tell you what 's wrong to me the industry's ability to manufacture stars.
They churn them out like Iwo Jima makes cars.
But the blame lies not with those suits for trying.
It's the sheep that keep on buying that soulless crap.
Whatever they put in front of ya.
The hysteria of America. - 311, Plain
I open this post with these lyrics from my favorite band 311 because in many ways I think these lyrics, originally intended as an indictment of the music industry, are equally appropriate as an indictment of the recruiting industry. Especially the corporate recruiting industry.
I have attended a few recruiting conferences, seminars and demoed (is that a word?) several recruiting products online over the last several months and I am continuously struck by a lack of uniqueness, differentiation and useable information that actually produce real world results for the recruiter on the front lines. I am equally disturbed by the intense reliance on technology, the monotonous beating of the ATS drums, the over emphasis of social networking as THE recruiting tool and the exorbitant amount of time we spend talking about sourcing.
All of the tired and worn out marketing, email spam blasts about these "solutions" and seemingly endless barrage of puffed upped promises that this tool or that technology will give you all you need to be a great recruiter. The key to being a great recruiter is not found in all of these alleged solutions. Nope, it is in hard work, building and maintaining relationships with strong talent and practicing the actual art and craft of recruiting. Not just sourcing, not just client management and not business development - recruiting. It is a lost art really. Funny how the very behavior and activity that defines us, indeed names us as an industry, is some how lost isn't it?
Sadly, recruiters keep gravitating to these things. In part out of ignorance of alternatives and in part because of the promises that are made. They buy services and products they don't need and are increasingly disappointed in the mysterious lack of results they achieve. I don't blame the vendors and the service providers really, though they do own some of the blame, rather I blame the recruiters themselves for continuing to pay for and give credibility to the presentation and not the substance. Too much show and not enough go!